- Israels right to exist - 1949 +

Posted by

Does Israel have a right to defend itself. 

In failing most of the first 11 questions to satisfy Israel is Jewish homeland by right and lawfully done, the last claims by zionist jews are twofold that;

1) God ordained that place for jews and not anyone else.

According to zionist israeli jews and supporters God promised jews , his children, the land of Canaan. here  , here . Its in their Torah of the exodus and in Ezekiel prophesis of jerusalems destruction and jews restoration to the land of "Israel" . Both which make up Part of the Old testament aka New testament in the Christian bible .


This claim wasnt the original reason for the zionist movement but has become part of the modern state of Israels social conditioning of the Israeli population and justification for its colonisation actions and treatment of Palestinians.

The Torah ‎ meaning  "Instruction", "Teaching" or "Law" is the compilation of the first five books of the Hebrew Bible, namely the books of Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy.

"Torah as a literary and ideological unity, based on earlier sources, was likely completed during the Persian period (539-333 BCE). Some scholars would place its final compilation somewhat later, however, in the Hellenistic period (333–164 BCE). Initially it had no authors but by 1st c CE had been attributed to Moses" , according to wikipedia. While " Torah (the first five books of the Bible) most likely took place during the Babylonian Exile (6th–5th century BCE)" according to Britannica, here

The israelites religion at the time was Yahwism . Yahwism was essentially polytheistic, with a plethora of gods and goddesses. YHWH , commonly written as Yahweh was one of the lesser gods of many.  Yahweh is represented as a storm god who marches into battle alongside stars and planets to defend Israel from enemies.

 After this , over time, other gods were discarded or were assimilated into Yahweh, who came to be referred to as El Shaddai: a title which roughly translates into English as “God Almighty.” This explains why he is such an evil god in the1st testament . As Richard Dawkins says .  



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YSy6ENVAJlY


Most of the religious writings are  unlikely true as it borrowed the flood and ark story from Sumer civilisation and other storys from other cultures. here .  Theres no proof of Moses and the exodus. here The human race is older than the 6,000 years claimed in the bible (by lineage from Adam and Eve). here

The "Star of David" on the israeli flag originally was used by many other non jews and was originally a symbol of magic .While a hexagram found in a religious context can be seen from a manuscript of the Hebrew Bible from 11th century Cairo. Its association as a distinctive symbol for the Jewish people and their religion dates back to 17th-century Prague. here. 

 The Jerusalem Talmud  or Palestinian Talmud , is a collection of rabbinic notes on the second-century Jewish oral tradition known as the Mishnah. Naming this version of the Talmud after Palestine or the Land of Israel—rather than Jerusalem—is considered more accurate, as the text originated mainly from Galilee in Byzantine Palaestina Secunda rather than from Jerusalem, where no Jews lived at the time. The 2nd part of the  Jerusalem Gemara contains the written discussions of generations of rabbis of the Talmudic Academies in Syria Palaestina at Tiberias and Caesarea, and was compiled into book form in around 350–400 CE. The Babylonian Talmud is written by "jews" in exile 200 years later.

Jews have very little affinity with christians as "Jews" dont believe Jesus Christ is the Messiah/Prophet sent by God . But a large section of Christianity supports Isreals colonisation and terrorism reframed as "right to protect itself"  because it has to because the whole first half of their modern christian bible includes teachings and writings of the jews in the first testament sometimes called the old testament which is their only claim of "proof" the existence of their christian God.

Evidenced by false christians such as Destiny church lead by Brian Tamaki who support israel but not Palestine thereby not following the teachings of their own bible (new testament- 2nd half). . When the teachings of christ as written in the bible are all about love, peace, respect ,turning the other cheek  and sharing wealth.  This is itself a un reconcilable contradiction with not only their words and actions of their support  of modern Israel (an apartheid terrorist state that is colonising Palestine) , but with no support of Palestine but it also contradicts the 1st testament which is an evil God who wants to destroy and enslave non jews and protect the land they conquered from the Canaanites.

As AI says

The Secular Zionism of Theodor Herzl (Late 19th Century)

  • Theodor Herzl, the founder of modern political Zionism in the late 19th century, envisioned Zionism primarily as a secular national movement. Herzl's goal was to establish a safe haven for Jews facing persecution, but he was not focused on religious ideas. His Zionism was more about national self-determination for the Jewish people, a response to the growing antisemitism in Europe.

  • Herzl’s book "Der Judenstaat" (The Jewish State), published in 1896, argued for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine, but it was conceived largely from a secular, pragmatic perspective, not as a religious return to the Biblical Land of Israel.

The Role of Religious Zionism (Early 20th Century)

While Herzl and many early Zionist leaders were secular, there were religious Jews who supported Zionism, though they were a minority in the early years. Religious Zionism developed as a movement that combined traditional Jewish beliefs with the nationalist ideals of Zionism.

  • Religious Zionism began to play a more prominent role in the movement after the First World War, especially as Jews in Palestine faced increasing tensions with the local Arab population and with other international powers. This was also when Jewish settlements in Palestine were growing, and some Jews emphasized religious ties to the land.

The 1948 Establishment of the State of Israel

When Israel was founded in 1948, the secular Zionist vision was dominant in the leadership, and the state was largely shaped by secular ideologies. Israel's Declaration of Independence emphasized Jewish self-determination but did not explicitly frame the state as a return to the "Holy Land" in a religious sense. The founders were mostly secular socialists and labor Zionists, and the state was seen as a secular refuge for Jews.

However, the religious significance of the land was still present for many Jews, both in Israel and in the diaspora, and the connection to the land was frequently invoked from a religious perspective.

Religious Zionism Gaining Influence in the 1960s-1970s

The turning point in religious Zionism came after the Six-Day War in 1967, when Israel captured East Jerusalem, the West Bank, and other historically significant lands in Jewish tradition, such as Hebron and the Golan Heights. This victory was seen by many as a miraculous event, and the religious significance of the land was emphasized more strongly in Israeli political discourse.

  • In the wake of this war, the idea of returning to the “holy land”—specifically Jerusalem—gained a much stronger foothold. For many religious Jews, the victory was seen as the fulfillment of biblical prophecy.

  • The religious dimension of Zionism became more pronounced as religious political parties, such as National Religious Party (NRP), began to gain influence in Israeli politics. These parties advocated for a stronger connection between religion and state and for the development of settlements in the occupied territories, which they saw as part of the biblical "Promised Land".

The 1970s-1980s: The Rise of Religious Zionism

From the 1970s onwards, religious Zionism became increasingly influential in Israeli politics, especially with the growth of Jewish settler movements in the West Bank and Gaza. These settlements were framed as a religious mission to reclaim the biblical land of Israel, and many religious leaders saw the establishment of Israel as part of a divine plan.

  • This period also saw the rise of political parties like Shas, which combined religious observance with political activism, and Gush Emunim, a group of religious Zionists who advocated for the settlement of the West Bank based on religious beliefs about the land.

Modern Israeli Politics: The Religious and Secular Divide

Today, Israel is a pluralistic society with a mix of secular and religious perspectives. The religious Zionist movement remains influential, especially in the context of the Jewish settlement movement in the occupied territories. However, there are still secular Jews in Israel who view Zionism primarily as a nationalist rather than a religious movement, emphasizing the security and self-determination of Jews rather than religious claims to the land.

Conclusion

The shift of Zionism from being a secular movement focused on nationalism to one that also emphasizes a religious return to the land of Israel largely developed after 1948 but became especially pronounced after 1967 with the Six-Day War. The victory in this war, coupled with the acquisition of Jerusalem and other historically significant territories, helped solidify the view of Israel’s existence as part of biblical prophecy and a return to the "Holy Land" for religious Jews. However, Zionism as a whole still maintains a significant secular component, particularly within the Israeli political system and its founding ideal.

Miko Peled explains how they dont even follow judaism zionism is an implant

How zionism manifests in liberals and more right wing conservatives Two faces of zionism

2) Hamas is a Islamic terrorist organisation who wants to destroy Israel and  attacked the established state of Israel unprovoked on 7oct 2023, so Israel has the right to "defend itself'  with as much force it wants and needs by destroying/ taking out the Islamic militant group Hamas along with thousands of civilians and infrastructure (and probably killing its own civilians -the hostages in the process)

This implication is Hamas is not practicing self defense .

To answer those questions we need to look at the history from 1949 until 7 oct 2023

First off states don't have rights, people have rights . States sign contracts and treaties and go to war or defend themselves.   The UN has declared humans have rights  here , to which both Israel and its  USA benefactor are signatories, here . This declaration does not give any rights to humans to have a state. People in reality have the rights we give them when we live together in a group, usually set out by governments. In Western liberal democracy's those rights are life , liberty (freedom) and to own property , usually enshrined in some Bill of Rights like in NZ  (BORA 1990 here ), UK (BOR 1689 here ) or USA (1st 10 constitution amendments  here).  States are usually the formation of a group of tribes or people in a bigger group with borders and a government always if not nearly always through violence. Those states governments are not always the voice of the people . States go to war for their political purposes ,and  have usually justified or manipulated the people in some way to accept that war,  as today most people do not want war.

It really comes down to what and how you describe the state of  Israel and Palestine. Israel has moved from a secular colonisation project to a far right wing ideology which has brought in a religious element and changed the definition of jew ,  manipulating and conditioning its own people , USA American's and christian's in the West. In a sense, we might say that the trajectory of contemporary Zionism has hopelessly conflated secular nationalism and religious ideology into one essential claim to historic Palestine. here

After the declaration of the state of Israel in 1948 and the resulting 1st Arab -Israeli war in 1948-1949 Egypt took control of Gaza strip and Jordan took control of West Bank until 1967.

In 1956 Israel led an attack on Gaza and Egypt to take control of Egypt's Suez canal , joined by France and Britain. They withdrew after outside pressure.
The secular Palestinian Liberation Organisation was founded in 1964.
In 1967 Israel attacked Egypt again to take control of the Suez canal again . Syria and Jordan attacked Israel in retaliation. Israel won and took Sinai Peninsula and the Golan heights and the rest of Palestine (Gaza Strip and West Bank)

Egypt closed Suez canal until 1975. Saudi Arabi , Kuwait,  Iraq, Libya and Algeria Banned oil shipments to USA, UK and Germany. 
Egypt and Syria and a coalition of Arab states attacked Israel in 1973 in Yom Kippur War or 4th Arab-Israeli war which was the last one. Israel ultimately repelled the attack and regained lost ground, but only after the United States made the decision to supply the Israeli military. Members of the Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries (OAPEC), led by King Faisal of Saudi Arabia, proclaimed an oil embargo targeted at nations that had supported Israel during the Yom Kippur War , leading to an oil crisis. This was part of the 1970s crises of capitalism that led us to allow governments to implement neo liberalism. 
In  1978 at Camp David negotiations Israel began returning Sinai Peninsula to Egypt from 1979 to fully in 1982.
Hamas was formed in 1987 during 1st intifada (Palestinian uprising), with its roots from the Muslim Brotherhood of Egypt [In September 2013, after their military coup an Egyptian court banned the Brotherhood to keep fundamentalist Islamism out]. Israel supported Hamas hoping it would divide the people and politics of Palestine to Break the PLO to ensure they had less unity and power so Israel could take more control of all of Palestine. here

Israel was confident in knowing what all non zionist's know is that Hamas or any other replacement government do not have the capacity to destroy Israel.

In 1988, with the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) intention to declare a Palestinian State, Jordan renounced all territorial claims to the West Bank, including East Jerusalem. 

Since the Palestinian Declaration of Independence in 1988, 135 UN Member Nations have recognized the State of Palestine. It has not been recognized by Israel and most Western nations, including the USA and NZ.

In 1993, following the Oslo Accords, parts of the territories politically came under the jurisdiction of the Palestinian National Authority (Palestinian enclaves, in West Bank) technically known as Areas A and B). Israel still exercised full military control and, civil control over 61% of the West Bank (Area C).

In 2005, Israel pulled all its remaining forces out of the Gaza Strip and dismantled its settlements. Nevertheless, according to the international community, the Gaza Strip is still considered to be occupied by Israel. Israel has denied that it occupies the Gaza Strip, but 3 of the 4 borders of the Gaza Strip, including the coast are controlled by Israel (the fourth border sector near Rafah is controlled by Egypt). Israel has a sea blockade and controls its airspace on the Gaza strip as reaction to Hamas. Hamas was supported by Israel in 2006 and won election in Gaza strip as government . Israel did this to spilt Palestine and Palestinians and weaken PLO to more easily control or colonise Gaza strip . This means all hospitals, schools, library's , rubbish collections etc are governed by Hamas. Hamas fought Fatah (offshoot of PLO)  in 2007 civil war and won and Israel soon changed its mind.

UN experts and even former British Prime Minister David Cameron have called (Gaza Strip) an “open air prison”.

The Golan Heights was under military administration until the Knesset passed the Golan Heights Law in 1981, which applied Israeli law to the territory; a move that has been described as an annexation. In response, the United Nations Security Council unanimously passed UNSC Resolution 497 which condemned the Israeli actions to change the status of the territory declaring them "null and void and without international legal effect", and that the Golan remained an occupied territory. In 2019, the United States became the only state to recognize the Golan Heights as Israeli sovereign territory, while the rest of the international community continues to consider the territory Syrian held under Israeli military occupation. here

 Israeli settlements are Jewish Israeli civilian communities built on Palestinian lands occupied by Israel since the 1967 Six-Day War. UN Resolution 2334 concerns such settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The Fourth Geneva Convention makes it illegal for nations to move populations and establish settlements in territories acquired in a war, and an overwhelming number of countries consider the Israeli settlements to be illegal on that basis. Israel states that these are not "occupied" but "disputed" territories because "there were no established sovereigns in the West Bank or Gaza Strip prior to the Six Day War". This argument was rejected by the International Court of Justice in 2004.  
   
And the Supreme Court of Israel, with a variety of different justices sitting, has repeatedly stated that Israel's presence in the West Bank is in violation of international law. here 

The UN has issued many resolutions against Israel , none recognised by Israel here
What the impotent UN thinks here
Israel has broken many other  UN resolutions , here
All because it has the backing of the west and in particular USA knowing the UN is toothless and impotent  not least because of USA and UK have veto powers and they use them to veto resolutions that would solve the conflict from colonisation.

Israel condemned many times , while the Palestine Authority haven't been once by the UN , short question time

Amnesty International explains the same here along with current war crimes , here

The current state of occupation in Palestinian West Bank by Israel with their unlawful wall explained  here.

as shown here 


An up to date map as at 6 October 2023 showing controlled areas (not claims of areas) here.



here, here, here  here , here, here

Israel does not have the right to defend itself when it is occupying power of someone else's territory by international law here

Ideally a single secular state is created, with Palestinians refugees returning giving an equal population and keeping fundamentalists on both sides out of parliament ie both current governments. 

This is looking less and less likely In which case the 2 state solution is the next best alternative  where Israel withdraws to the proposed woodhouse borders where both Palestine and Israel have 2 separate single states as should have happened once the single state was rejected by the Jews. or at least the 1949 armistice borders with shared Jerusalem.

The problem is  zionist Jew fundamentalists who view the land as theirs and wont share while  Hamas have changed their stance. Israel does not now recognise the proposed UN 1947 borders or the 1949 armistice green line borders or 1967 borders. While many states including all the Arab states do recognise the 1967 borders. In fact given Israel's declaration the West Banks not occupied but disputed it really does not recognise Palestine's right of state . This has been a major contention in any peace deals between Israel and Palestine.  The other contention is the Palestinian right of return , the political position or principle that Palestinian refugees [both first-generation refugees and their descendants] have a right to return, and a right to the property they themselves or their forebears left behind or were forced to leave in what is now Israel and the Palestinian territories. UN General Assembly Resolution 3236, passed on 22 November 1974 declared the right of return to be an "inalienable right". 

Most world leaders support the 2 state solution to the Israeli-Palestine conflict.  The Palestinian leadership has embraced the concept since the 1982 Arab Summit in Fez, and in 2017 Hamas accepted the idea of a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders. 

But currently most Palestinians believe that a two-state solution is unlikely to emerge from the conflict. Instead, a majority of them say they prefer to reclaim all of historic Palestine, including the pre-1967 Israel. A one-state solution with Arabs and Jews holding equal rights comes in second. Similarly, recent polling from PCPSR finds support among Palestinians and Israeli Jews for a two-state solution has dropped to 43 percent and 42 percent, respectively. here. 

In December 2022, support for a two-state solution was 33% among Palestinians, 34% among Israeli Jews, and 60% among Israeli Arabs. 82% of Israeli Jews and 75% of Palestinians believed that the other side would never accept the existence of their independent state. here

3rd option - is a 3 state solution where former American ambassador to the United Nations John R. Bolton has suggested a "'three-state' approach, where Gaza is returned to Egyptian control and the West Bank in some configuration reverts to Jordanian sovereignty".  Much further down on the options desired by Palestine. 

4th option - no state solution- ie  all lands of historic Palestine would be internationalized, and would become part of a new United Nations ‘Trust Territory’ (UNTT).here 

The Wests complicity [either supporting Israel or doing nothing] in the conflict allows for it to remain unsettled  which allows  Israel to continue to this day to terrorise Palestinians, detaining and  imprisoning them, killing them without consequences , on whims and made up rules that suit Israel while it continues to occupy and settle more  Palestinian land thereby stealing it. The population of Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem, grew from 520,000 to more than 700,000 between 2012 and 2022, according to the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. 

Geo politics of Palestine 

 USA was historically anti "Jew" (what people mistakenly call anti-semite) like most European countries here . But now USA is one of the main supporters of  Israel in propaganda and money . USA support is one of the main reasons for Israel's belligerence, arrogance and success in defending its colonisation of Palestine. This is because USA is not interested in justice. It is interested in control and maintaining its empire . Its record speaks for itself. 
It simultaneously hypocritically funds Israel's military and colonisation of Palestine and vetoes UN resolutions to solve the crises while often brokering peace deals . USA does not want peace nor does it want war it wants instability . This way Israel needs USA support and in turn Arab countries detest or fear Israel and this means USA can then control the Arab countries as well, like it does  Egypt . Egypt once a victim of colonisation and Israel's wars now is more or less a supporter of Israel. here . Not just for the USA money but to keep out the Islamic state (Hamas) The conflict and crises created Hamas and in turn Egypt wants to keep Hamas and other radical Muslim groups like the brotherhood out so is no friend of Gaza. 
Once a peaceful solution is found in Palestine. USA will have less control over all the countries in the conflict. Israel is a anti Arab state in the middle of the Middle East that USA wants there as a semi puppet state the same as Russia wanted Belarus and Ukraine (albeit for different reasons -  to keep NATO at bay).


USA politicians want to get Tiktok to ban pro Palestinian views. here

Israel is so arrogant and self assured of USA support it writes the names of USA citizens , critical of Israel's behaviour, on their bombs they drop on Palestinian civilians. 

President Truman explaining how they could not give all Palestine to zionist Jews in one go, but had to do it with duplicity slowly over time , here.

 1) "Israel is the largest cumulative recipient of U.S. foreign aid: until February 2022, the United States had provided Israel US$150 billion (non-inflation-adjusted) . About half of USAs foreign aid was going to Israel . Of which in 1999, the US government signed a Memorandum of Understanding through which it committed to providing Israel with at least US$2.67 billion in military aid annually, for the following ten years; in 2009, the annual amount was raised to US$3 billion; and in 2019, the amount was raised again, now standing at a minimum of US$3.8 billion that the US is committed to providing Israel each year." here  ,  here.

Egypt is the recipient of the 2nd biggest amount of aid from USA , which like Israel goes on military, here. and will explain its reluctance to help Gaza anymore. In order to keep Israel in power and Arab countries subdued in a very co-dependent relationship between Israel and USA.  No other countries come close.


2) In Noam Chompsky's book "Hegemony Or Survival - America's Quest For Global Dominance" in chapter 7 , he discusses the USA veto's on security council resolutions to end the Palestine-Israel conflict. . While  Al Jazeera numbers veto's as  56  . here . here






Its about oil;



The 1960s proposed Ben Gurion canal as alternative to Suez canal , is longer because it has to avoid Gaza- if Israel controlled Gaza 100% ie without resistance then it would be shorter and cheaper .  here



But there's much much more to it than just oil , its about about power and control , hegemony.

Joe Biden said in 1986 "Where there not an Israel United states of American  would have to invent an Israel to protect its interests in the region"

Since the ending of the cold war with Russia in the 1990s the stated foreign policy in the 1992 Wolfowitz Doctrine declares  USA  number world superpower and remaining that way in large part by controlling the rest of the world. USA has over  800 military bases in over 70 countries around the world to fulfil this and spends more than the next 9 biggest military spenders.. here 

Paul Wolfowitz was an American born Jewish neo-con son of a into a Polish Jewish immigrant family
Wolfowitz was the sole representative of the Bush administration to attend, speaking alongside Former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani. at the National Solidarity Rally for Israel in Washington to promote US support and collaboration with Israel.  He later planned the invasion of Iraq.







The problem with Christian zionism, especially in USA 





Heres a short doco on USA politicians lies and coverage of  Hamas reasons for oct7th


The Lobby – USA  , a four-part undercover investigation by Al Jazeera into Israel’s covert influence campaign in the United States


Israel is the last western colonisation program .  The world has rejected colonisation since WWII with much of it especially in Asia and Africa becoming uncolonised over decades with Namibia only decolonised in 1990 while Canada , USA,  Australia and NZ still are not and will never truely be decolonised. . And is why the world did not object to the creation of the state of Israel.









German Police enforce governments pro Israel anti Palestine stance

14 USA states Attorney Generals attempting ban any reporting on Hamas threatens journalism.

Former Greek economics minister Ioannis Georgiou "Yanis" Varoufakis speaks out also


Israel's new ultra right nationalist helped bring  the current far right government to power.

These settlers are terrorising Palestinians with impunity - they are ethnic cleansing the West Bank

Palestinian West Bank land is being sold for zionists only in US here , here , here

Hamas 

Hamas is the Government of Gaza strip .It is Ilamist based . While it was elected in in 2006  . Fatah resisted Hamas election started a civil war which Hamas won. Hamas has not had an election since. .  The current  far right current in Israel government and groups like Hamas rise due to need not religion as was the case of ISIS in Syria .  These views are the extreme not the majority , but prohibit peace. here

None the less Hamas was supported by the Israeli government to weaken PLO and divide Palestinian s initially. here


While these secular Palestinians dominated the scene during the 1970s, religious movements also grew. The failure of Arab nationalism in the 1967 war resulted in the strengthening of both progressive and extremist Islamic movements. here

.  



Scott Ritter also covers Israel's creation of Hamas and its real intent as I have mentioned.


This touches on Hamas reasons for attack and Israel's solution.

The occupation and settlements in Palestine and Golan heights are considered illegal here

Palestinian Homes Are Being Demolished in Jerusalem,




homes stolen 

settler violence on Palestinians

All of the above

2 Ex Israeli soldier explaining the colonisation and its indoctrinated culture.

Israel is a terrorist state

The definition of terrorism from oxford dictionary;
  1. "the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.
    "the fight against terrorism"

While no western government is willing to call Israel a terrorist state many middle east countries have. Countries that have condemned Israel's role as a perpetrator of state-sponsored terrorism or state terrorism include Bolivia,Iran, Lebanon,Saudi Arabia,Syria,[6]Turkey,and Yemen.[     

Ex Israeli soldier says he was the terrorist



Avner Gvaryahu director of Breaking the Silence an organisation of 1300 ex soldiers   breaks the silence on the occupation since 1967.



and this is terrorism - 13yo old Palestinian held on no charges - a hostage  a cause of 7th oct

ex military explaining the futile nature of Israel propaganda



Israel's role in war crimes committed during the Guatemalan civil war here

Israeli sniper murders 2 catholic Christian women in Gaza, here

Israeli sniper intentionally murdered USA journalist Shireen Abu Akleh .

Which is a pattern of behaviour


And its got worse Israel accused of targeting journalists @ 21 Dec 2023

This Al Jazeera article explains Hamas attacks of which the important 2 points boil down to Israel terrorism in West Bank and falling ability to make a Palestinian state due to it and western complicity . here or here. With 155 Palestinians killed in Israel occupied West Bank last year in 2022 and 172 this year alone before Oct 7th , at a time of no conflict. 

Palestine PM calls on the world to stop Israel's crimes of Apartheid .  Which are explained here here 

 In August 2023 Israel's far right minister Ben-vir said its his right to freely move around the occupied West Bank is superior to the freedom of movement for Palestinians. here. 

Explained in this 9 min video here 

Pakistan Ambassador speaks out against Israel

Russel Betrand's 1970 letter speaking out against Israel's aggression just before he died  and nothing has  changed.

Ex Israeli soldier gives a view on Israel's terrorism





Palestinian civilian deaths from occupation terrorism, excluding foreign doctors journalists and supporters like American Rachel Alien Corrie murdered 2003. Which Israel has just more than doubled in 3 weeks in oct 2023 alone.

Genocide

In the latest conflict its 99% certain Israel has targeted a hospital and killed at least 500 including babies . We say this because although IJC contradicts this here. everything screams Israel did it .The size of the blast is much bigger than Hamas home made rockets could manage. Israel made threats to bomb the hospital days before,  has accused Hamas of operating from under hospitals and schools ,  has lied about doing the same thing before. Has bombed 30% of Gaza. Israel doesnt care about killing its own citizens , so why would they apply different position to their occupied people who they care for less. The leadership has said so, days ago Israeli President Isaac Herzog blamed Palestinian civilians in Gaza as a whole for Hamas’s October 7 attack: “It is an entire nation out there that is responsible.” here here. Which even the UN denounces, here. here here   

Bombing a church here

7 World Central Food kitchen staff targeted intentionally murdering them in 3 separate drone strikes.

Nearly 200 historical sites destroyed here here
1000 out of  1200 mosques destroyed here
90% of school buildings destroyed or damaged and all universities destroyed here
Every hospital in Gaza is either damaged, destroyed, or out of service due to lack of fuel; only 13 hospitals are even partially functioning. here

Destruction covered here updated 3 may 2024 here .


All to " destroy Hamas" the government of Gaza so they say .

This forms part of the basis of South Africas case of Genocide against Israel which the ICJ failed to rule adequately using double speak The ICJ did not call for an immediate cease-fire, nor did it rule on whether Israel is in fact committing a genocide, but it did instruct Israel to take provisional measures to prevent genocidal acts.

While killing civilians is indefensible but sometimes collateral damage as here we should not be surprised every nation denouncing it has practiced intentional killing of civilians in war especially by  Germany (on Warsaw, Poland)  , Japan (on China) ,   Britain (under Churchill on Dresden, Germany)  and the worst country  USA in WW2 on Dresden and Japan and more recently USA in  Asia in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia and still more recently in Iraq this century when it suited them.

None the less Israel's response to  Izz ad Din al-Qassam Brigades (in short Al-Qassam and Hamas in error) ) attack 7 oct is out of proportion and the civilian deaths are war crime and Britain and USA are complicit as they provide weapons and support.

Prime Ministers Netanyahu's references to violent biblical passages raise alarm among critics

At a controversial meeting of Chicago council voting to support Israel's genocide Gabriel Miller speaks out against the Israeli zionist supporters , exposing the hypocrites of the international community and its complicity in Gaza genocide at Chicago council . here

Raphael Lemkin, a Polish-Jew documented Nazi atrocities in his 1944 book, Axis Rule in Occupied Europe. In this text, he introduced the word “genocide. First described genocide as  we mean the destruction of a nation or of an ethnic group genocide does not necessarily mean the immediate destruction of a nation, except when accomplished by mass killings of all members of a nation. It is intended rather to signify a coordinated plan of different actions aiming at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves. Genocide is directed against the national group as an entity, and the actions involved are directed against individuals,  as members of the national group”  

While genocide is defined by UN as;
DEFINITION OF GENOCIDE IN THE CONVENTION: The current definition of Genocide is set out in Article II of the Genocide Convention: Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: 
(a) Killing members of the group; 
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; 
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; 
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; 
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group
from here. 

When everyone calls it genocide Israel's reaction is to deny the Palestinian people exist or had a culture ergo not genocide. and allows you to carry on against international outrage. Israel's finance minister Bezal Smotrich an ultra nationalist member of Israel's ruling coalition and responsible for for administering the West Bank claimed there is no such thing as Palestinian culture, history or people in march 2023  here


Indoctrination


The acceptance by a very large part of Israel's occupation , war crimes and genocide is possible through indoctrination

Ex military now run a Breaking the Silence project established 2004 against Israels colonisation


Jewish-American  activist Maya Edery on her journey away from Zionist Israeli  indoctrination.

Ilan Pappe explains his indoctrination at 10m 10 s 

Miko Peled explains how Israel indoctrinates its people explains schools are prohibited from descussing Nakba - the military presented as heroes not systemic terrorists but occasional instances.


Simone Zimmerman in 1 min video on her  indoctrination


 
The media mostly driven by western media is on the side of Israel here . here and they still quote Hamas killing 1400 Israelis even thou its well proven lies.

Zionist fascism

Zionist Israeli Jews especially its government are a fanatical, nationalistic, militaristic, extremely xenophobic, racist political identity with a political purpose hidden under a veil of  fundamentalists religion of a made up god, claiming they have a right ordained by that god to live in an area they stole and have lived in about a 5% of the time of civilisation as a sovereign state and 1/3 of time as majority population of civilisation in that area since they first conquered the land from others. If they (zionist Israelis)  are not then Israel Government they voted for to continue apartheid and commit genocide is not democratic.

Israel and their "Jew" zionism closely resembles the core ideology of  NAZI fascism . Hitler wanted to rebuild the German empire in the Third Reich,  rebuilding a once great lost empire built on blood and sand and need for more territory (Lebensraum aka living space/land in German) over less than human (Slavs in Hitler's case) occupants,  for their economy and population . The nation  is so nationalistic the people work for the nation not the other way around. Described here. Hitler  was racist and considered the Aryan the superior "race" and Jews inferior and did not want to mix Aryan blood with Jew blood so wanted them expelled (least before holocaust of 1941). Hitler and NAZIS considered Slavs less than human. This was reflected in their Volkisch equality
The Nazis heavily reduced media agency numbers and controlled the media .
Fascism is a far right wing ideology.
NAZIsm was set up as a third way not capitalism or socialism ,.

Zionist Jews in Israel state (Govt) fulfil much of this ;
- Recreate the fabled mythical once great kingdom of Israel built on blood and sand
- The whole project was born as colonisation , the need for stealing land and evicting the occupiers for living space, its still an expansionist ideology.
- Jews work for the state as born out by the Hannibal directive and treatment of hostages (see last page video link) , conscripted army and zionist Israel state conditioning/brainwashing .
- Many Jews feel they do not want Arabs in Israel or Palestine so they do not water down their blood. here . This is reflected in their treatment of non zonist Jews in NAZI like Volkisch equality .
- Israel is prepared to practice pogrom thou most critics call it genocide.
- Frenetic brainwashing 
- Revisionist modern zionist's quote bible , believe they are gods chosen  (superior)  ones.
- Current Israel has completely prevented journalists entering Gaza from 7 oct 2023  but have have managed to murder 63 journalists so far. here
- Unlike NAZI dictatorship Israel is still considered a democracy (least for "Jew" citizens) . But the current Israel Government is tryin to restrict supreme court  power  and independence thereby restricting separation of powers reducing democracy. Israeli Ashkenazi Jew Professor of history, Ilan Pappe does not think Israel is a democracy either israel-cannot-be-a-colonial-power-and-a-democracy 
- Israel has banned Al-Jazeera operating in Palestine here and Netanyahu is calling for free speech to be stopped in other country's Netanyahu confused which country hes PM of ?
- Current Israel government is the most right wing with far right coalition partners..
- Netanyahu and other right wing politicians call Palestinians animals.
- Israel minister of Heritage calls for more painful deaths for Palestinians, here
- Zionism project was originally envisaged  as a way between capitalism and socialism.

Here is Ex Israeli Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked campaigning on fascism Election Ad: Fascism By Ayelet Shaked . In hebrew with english subtitles added.

Ex holocaust survivor says so, here .here

It should come as no surprise Israel's partner in crime and benefactor USA is the other country that closely resembles fascist ideology. USA is the largest terrorist organisation in the world and has been since WW2. Its founded in its Manifest Destiny , its American Exceptionalism , its racism and slavery and white supremacy , its stealing of native lands and its nation state built on "blood and sand" , its non left history , its anti communism brainwashing . Kennedy famously said "ask not what your country can do for you but ask what you can do for your country" , serving the state  is NAZIsm born from conservatism when we supposed to live in a liberal democracy where the state serves you.




Dont take my word for it




Video on Israel's roadmap to apartheid  A shocking insight into Israels apartheid

Noam Chompsky who called USA the biggest threat to world peace schools zionist journalist who defends Isarale & USA terrorism 

While Israel's not strictly in the same category as NAZI Germany,  as there is 20% Arabs / Muslim's still living in Israel but they do not have the same rights, its about the very close similarities to an ideology, here . Israel has reduced the supreme court powers to make itself less accountable ergo reducing democracy .

You could say Israel is protecting itself but that's not true. The state of Israel is bigger than the original UN partition plan , bigger than the green line after the 1949 war . Israel is not a victim of this conflict,   it is the primary perpetrator and aggressor. Palestine is the victim of colonisation first by Britain then by Israel.

Zionist Israel wants all Palestine land and or subjugation by Palestinians and will never change their mind or sue for peace or agree to even a 2 state solution. In a few more decades this whole map [below of Palestinian land loss] will be white because the world sat by and did nothing. Including the New Zealand Government who adds its voice to the oppressors without criticising their actions but simply calls for ceasefire when conflict blows up.   here . While earlier versions of the MFAT webpage on Palestine were much more biased in favour of Israel. This latest webpage here you will notice is much better,  thou still slightly biased. It condemns Hamas as a terrorist organisation but not Israel . Instead of Israel's right too defend itself it is now Israel's right to peace and security (implying same thing). It talks of Palestine's right to a state and security but not to peace .


Pushback by Jews against zionist Israel

As mentioned in part 1 not all Jews support Israel as as homeland or Israel's colonisation of Palestine or of Palestine's part of the UN partition land.
Even some progressive Jews speak out against the zionist "Jew" war crimes, thou clearly some are having trouble now for the first time Israeli deaths exceeded Palestinian deaths temporarily although this has been remedied in the last 4 weeks.  here, here.  
This Rabbi took decades to reject zionist Israel and its brainwashing and gets punished for it . here
Orthodox Jews also speak out against Israel's behaviour  here here
As do noted professors like Noam Chompsky here  
Watch the Israeli  police violently oppose orthodox Jews at the 5m30s mark here
Young Israelis refuse to serve , here  here, here





Even left wing Israeli's are not free from persecution by Israeli state for calling it out.




Israels goal is complete control of all of former Palestine without pushback

This is clear in its words and in its actions. 


While Hamas had in its former charter the destruction of Israel until it softened its stance allowing creation of a Palestinian State which implies a State of Israel to exist. here But the same cant be said of Netanyahu and Lukid Pary.  Netanyahu's Lukid party also have the same explicit goals of  the destruction of the Palestine state which has in its forming Charter , here



Wikipedia list only Netanyahu as rejecting a 2 state solution here
This video explains Netanyahu wants Hamas to attack Israel to justify no 2 state and the genocide is about dominating Palestine.

Tzipi Hotovely Israeli ambassador to UK In 2023 says no 2 state solution,


Israels ambassador to UK says there wont be a 2 state solution and that every second house has tunnel access and this is reason enough to destroy the whole of Gaza killing thousands of innocent children

Netanyahu and zionist Israel and zionists do not want a single state or a 2 state solution , what they want is total control of occupied Palestine without resistance and an apartheid state where  where Israel can practice genocide and terrorism on Palestinians because they are not Israeli citizens but occupied aliens and so do not have the same rights especially human rights .Some view this as Israels goal and some view it as zionists Israels temporary setup .

As outlined in an interview between Toufic Haddad and Ilan Pappé Israel’s emergent political formations believe alternatives to Oslo exist and should be considered and potentially exercised, including declaration of unapologetic Jewish-supremacist apartheid, total annexation of the OPT and ethnic cleansing of those who resist.  This apartheid state might not be temporary if no other "jews" immigrate to Israel and the ratio of zionist Jews to Palestinian Arabs is not high enough.. here

Latest at 9 may 2024 building settlements in Gaza  here

Former President Jimmy Carter (2006) emphasised that the Oslo interim agreement was an apartheid solution, not for an independent Palestinian state. The US has talked about a two-state solution but has so far been unwilling to put any pressure to end the expansion of settlements and remove separation barriers on Palestine lands or dismantle check points and remove bypass roads only for settlers (see Figure 3). “And therefore, we should acknowledge that the Oslo process was not a fair and equal pursuit of peace, but a compromise agreed to by a defeated, colonised people” here .


Israels lies about 7 oct

On the 7th October 2023 attack by Al-Qassam into Israel that took hostages and deaths occurred.. Where Israel claimed 1400 killed included babies beheaded and 250  hostages taken. But thats a lie and now the truth comes out


First they reduced the 1400 to 1200

Now its lower again . here

Lies about babies behead were already being repeated by media and politicians while being questioned as not credible days after 7oct , The Media's Israel Palestine Misinformation War

                              New York times weaponised Hamas rape story is a fraud

In debunked segment from Zateo here

This Israeli hostage say she was treated well which contrasts story's like Mias, here
While this is about a complicit zionist British journalist the first part Owen Jones talks about Israel treatment of its hostages British Journalist 

That IDF killed many Israelis intentionally or accidently because of protocol,  zealousness  and ineptitude.
.





Where he points out Israel's Hannibal direct dictates that Israel murders all captive soldiers to prevent negotiation. It seems they practised that on 7 Oct and looks that way with the 200 + Hamas hostages of Israelis where there's no attempt to save them.


Hamas says it went to get soldiers to exchange for Palestinian hostages held by Israel and civilians were collateral damage. Their statements from 3min   here

And since 

Its hard to believe Israel even wants the hostages back alive , that its not a political tool.  here

Leaving aside the murder of its own citizens which may/may not  be part of the false flag there's some facts beginning to emerge that point to an event similar to 911  that makes it look like 7oct was aided as inside job by Israel.
Israel knew a year in advance of a coming attack here
Egypt warned Israel days before Al-Qassam struck, US committee chairman says. 
The festival was supposed to finish the day before on oct 6
Prior stock market movement looked like someone knew here
It took 7-10 hrs for IDF to respond officially.


I take this with a grain of salt  being a conspiratorial web site  (here) but non the less there will be grain truth in here. for eg a i cant confirm 700 soldiers died  - Israel's only saying 600 since 7th oct.

Here that's Washington Post article quoted

None the less all this explains why Israel blocks any UN investigation of 7th Oct in case its shown to the world.

But what's is to be done now ?

Israel has got bolder and more arrogant the more it does and no one in the west or its institutions (UN) is prepared to stop them . And, without consequences Israel wont stop until it controls all of Palestine. 
Either the Arab Nations unify and obliterate Israel once and for all or we make the BDS so big it cripples Israel economically or both Israel and USA face charges of genocide in a court or USA is somehow forced to stop funding Israel's terrorism of Palestine. That's unlikely to happen.

[edit: Israel was been taken to the International Court of Justice ( ICJ) in 2023 by South Africa and they ruled Israel must take steps to prevent genocide just short of actually calling it genocide but said as much and settlements in the west Bank are illegal . It followed up in July 2024 with a report . In 21 November 2024, following an investigation of war crimes and crimes against humanity, the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued arrest warrants for two senior Israeli officials, Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel, and Yoav Gallant, the former Minister of Defense of Israel]

Other considerations

Regardless of your views it should be dawning on you the failure of goals of 

The UN - they helped set up the Israeli colonisation project and its current conflict and have failed to stop Israel's colonisation and terrorism of Palestine and the Israeli Palestine conflict.
Not surprising as they failed in Rwanda conflict , they set up the  Indonesian  colonisation of  West Papua 1962 , failing in the current Ukraine conflict,

Failure of "Jewish" values -   Israel is destroying itself from within . Not only in allowing its government to move to extreme right resembling elements of fascism which goes hand in hand  with  destroying all its so called values it espouses What are Jewish Values ?

This should be very alarmist for the world and says the world is no a safe place from conflict unless its going to be resolved by American diplomacy ie coercion and guns: and especially for non western countries. 

Zionists claim Arabs drove out jews out of surrounding Arab muslim countrys -not withstanding israels hand by terrorism in this in Iraq and Egypt this is somewhat true. But it wasnt because Arabs and jews didnt live peacefully it was because right wing govt saw a convienent enemy to blame. Here its explined by arab jew , the left, communists supported the jews. Its the right wing in israel now going to war against palestinians . its right wing in USA supporting that (both parties Democrats and Republicans are right wing- just republicans are more right wing with conservative social views). 


Conclusion

Israel is the aggressor and bully here going back to not only 1948 but further to about 1929. For Israel to claim it has a right to protect itself  it cannot be a coloniser and occupier and terroriser of Palestine . Which is condemned by the UN and most of the world . It must withdraw to the 1949 green line borders and negotiate permanent peace.

If the West opposes the war of Russia in Ukraine then it must in fair justice oppose Israel's colonisation and war on occupied Palestine.

In summary Edward Said said it best  here


Time line of Palestine to Israel and since here



Comments

Post a Comment